According to thousands of Peloton treadmill Reddit reviews, the answer is a resounding yes—for the right person. Owners highlight the immersive classes, leaderboard motivation, and sturdy build quality as justifying the investment. However, Redditors also advise: only buy if you’ll consistently use the classes. For casual walkers, a cheaper treadmill + the Peloton app might suffice. For serious runners, the Tread and Treadmill Plus are considered top-tier.